When I heard that Bryan Lee O'Malley's indie comic series
Scott Pilgrim was getting a movie adaptation, I was more than a little skeptical. While the current
Dark Knight-chasing superhero movie craze proves that it's possible to adapt comic
heroes, there have been very few successful attempts to actually adapt
comics. In fairness, superhero comics, which dominate the American market to a ludicrous extent, don't lend themselves naturally to it - there is no overarching plot to Superman's story, or Batman's, but rather origin stories and then about seventy years of interlocking, self-contradictory, increasingly bizarre plots (is Bruce Wayne still dead, by the way? Or did
Blackest Night fix that?) that you can't really make into a film because they depend on everything before them. The few limited series that do get adaptations -
Watchmen,
V for Vendetta, this year's
Kick-Ass - tend to either lose what made a good series good or make a bad one hilariously worse.
Scott Pilgrim vs. the World, directed by Edgar Wright (
Shaun of the Dead, Hot Fuzz) now joins that not-so-illustrious list.
Well, it is a rather decent adaptation of
Scott Pilgrim. In fact, I would say it's better as a movie than
Scott Pilgrim was as a comic book. If only that were saying much. Spoilers ahead.